Why Your Child Won't Take Responsibility (and What to Do About It)
Why Your Child Won't Take Responsibility (and What to Do About It)
Few things frustrate parents more than hearing:
"It wasn't me."
Or:
"It's not a big deal."
Or even worse:
"I don't know what you're talking about."
When your child hides a mistake, lies about what happened, or seems to avoid responsibility, it's easy to worry.
Will they grow up blaming everyone else?
Will they become someone who never admits when they're wrong?
The good news is that most children aren't avoiding responsibility because they lack character.
More often, they're trying to protect themselves from uncomfortable feelings.
Understanding that difference completely changes how we respond.
Why Taking Responsibility Matters
One of the core values many parents hope to teach is taking responsibility.
We want our children to become adults who:
Admit mistakes
Repair relationships
Learn from failures
Accept consequences
Keep growing
These skills help children become trusted friends, teammates, coworkers, and partners.
That's why it feels so concerning when kids seem determined to avoid responsibility every chance they get.
But before assuming the worst, it's worth asking an important question.
Why would a child choose to hide a mistake in the first place?
Sometimes Kids Just Want the Problem to Go Away
Think back to your own childhood.
Have you ever broken something and hoped no one would notice?
Or forgotten an assignment and wished it would somehow disappear?
Most adults have.
Children often think the same way.
When something goes wrong, their first instinct isn't necessarily deception.
It's relief.
"If no one knows, maybe it never happened."
Young children especially don't fully understand long-term consequences.
Their brains are looking for the quickest way to escape the uncomfortable feeling.
Sometimes that means hiding evidence.
Sometimes it means denying what happened.
Sometimes it means insisting it "isn't a big deal."
These are all ways children may avoid responsibility because they're trying to avoid shame, fear, or disappointment.
Fear Makes Honesty Hard
Another common reason children struggle with taking responsibility is fear.
They may worry about:
Getting in trouble
Disappointing their parents
Losing privileges
Being yelled at
Feeling embarrassed
If children believe admitting a mistake will always lead to overwhelming criticism, they naturally become more motivated to hide it.
That's why effective parenting isn't just about teaching accountability.
It's also about creating emotional safety.
What Is Psychological Safety?
One of the most interesting ideas discussed in this episode comes from business research.
High-performing teams often share one important quality:
Psychological safety.
This means people feel safe admitting mistakes because they know they won't be judged as failures.
Instead, mistakes become opportunities to learn.
Families can create that same environment.
This doesn't mean mistakes have no consequences.
It means children know that making one mistake does not define who they are.
That distinction is incredibly important.
Effective Parenting Starts With Modeling
Children learn much more from watching us than listening to us.
One of the strongest parenting tips you can use is admitting your own mistakes out loud.
For example:
"I forgot to take dinner out of the freezer."
"I missed that appointment."
"I should have handled that conversation differently."
Then explain what you'll do next time.
This teaches children that taking responsibility isn't something we demand from them.
It's something everyone practices.
That's one of the most powerful examples of effective parenting.
Replace Lectures With Curiosity
Imagine your child accidentally stains the couch with markers.
Instead of immediately saying:
"What were you thinking?"
Try asking:
"Can you tell me what happened?"
That simple shift changes everything.
Curiosity creates conversation.
Lectures often create defensiveness.
One of the best parenting tips is remembering that understanding comes before problem-solving.
When children feel heard, they're much more likely to stay engaged instead of shutting down.
Praise the Truth, Not Just the Outcome
Many parents focus on the mistake itself.
But there's another behavior worth celebrating.
Honesty.
If your child admits what happened, even after making a poor choice, recognize that courage.
You might say:
"I know that wasn't easy to tell me."
"I'm really proud that you told me the truth."
This reinforces the exact behavior you want to see again.
Even if there still needs to be a consequence.
That's an important distinction.
Acknowledging honesty doesn't erase accountability.
It strengthens it.
Consequences Still Matter
Creating psychological safety does not mean eliminating consequences.
Sometimes children need to:
Apologize
Repair something they damaged
Replace a broken item
Accept a logical consequence
The difference is that consequences happen without attacking the child's character.
Instead of:
"You're so irresponsible."
We focus on:
"What can we do to make this right?"
That's the heart of effective parenting.
Raising Kids Who Own Their Mistakes
Children don't become responsible because they fear making mistakes.
They become responsible because they learn mistakes are survivable.
When families normalize taking responsibility, children begin seeing mistakes as opportunities to learn instead of evidence that they're bad people.
That mindset makes honesty much easier.
And over time, children become less likely to avoid responsibility because they know the truth will be met with guidance instead of shame.
Final Thoughts
Every child makes mistakes.
Every parent does too.
The goal isn't raising children who never mess up.
The goal is raising children who can admit when they do.
By modeling taking responsibility, responding with curiosity instead of criticism, practicing effective parenting, and using thoughtful parenting tips , you can create a home where honesty feels safe.
And when children no longer feel they have to avoid responsibility, they become far more willing to learn, repair, and grow.
That's a lesson that will serve them for the rest of their lives.
LET'S CONNECT:
Love having expert tips you can actually use? Join our newsletter and get a beautifully designed PDF of each episode’s top 3 takeaways—delivered straight to your inbox every week.
Are you a provider? Subscribe here for professional insights and parenting resources!
-
[00:00:00] Leah Clionsky: When your child makes a mistake or when they do something they shouldn't do, do they tell you about it? Do they come to you? Or do they avoid it, hide it, or try to dismiss it as not a big deal? Lots of the parents I work with come to me because that they are concerned that their child is not taking responsibility for their actions.
[00:00:24] Leah Clionsky: They're worried that their child doesn't own their mistakes, won't acknowledge them, and then won't make the necessary repairs after they've messed up. It's a common problem, so that's what we're gonna be talking about in today's episode of Educated Parent.
[00:00:42] Leah Clionsky: Why are parents very concerned if their child doesn't, in their mind, quote-unquote, "take responsibility" for mistakes? Why does it worry parents when their kids won't acknowledge when they've done something they shouldn't do? Well, that's because it maps onto a core value that many of us have as parents called conscientiousness.
[00:01:05] Leah Clionsky: I know it's a hard one to say. Conscientiousness is the idea that we should be trying our best, and then when we mess up, if we do something that doesn't work, which is part of being a human, that we're able to own that, tell other people about it, t-take any fallout that might happen for that, and be willing to do something differently the next time, make those repairs in relationships if possible.
[00:01:35] Leah Clionsky: One of the reasons why we value conscientiousness is it's part of what makes us a reliable part of a team. If somebody covers up their mistakes, won't admit when they mess up, won't apologize or repair relationships when they need to, that person's probably very, very hard to work with, and that's not what we want for our kids, right?
[00:01:56] Leah Clionsky: We want them to have good relationships where they can make mistakes, acknowledge them, and repair, good working relationships where they can do the same. I mean, that even plays out into sports teams, right? What makes a good team member? We don't want people walking around saying, "Yep, everything I do is perfect, and if you call me out on it, I'm gonna blow up."
[00:02:15] Leah Clionsky: So this is a trait that many of us find to be very highly valuable, and then we feel really concerned when our kids are not showing behaviors consistent with that trait. And then we say things like, "Well, he never takes responsibility for his actions." So what does that usually mean when we say someone doesn't take responsibility?
[00:02:37] Leah Clionsky: Um, maybe it means that they hide the mistake. So they do something, they mess up, and they specifically hide it so that you can't find it, and just hope that no one will ever know. Um, sometimes they lie about it. You're like, "Did you do this?" And they say, "No," and they did do that, and you find out later, and then you're really frustrated because to you it reflects on their moral character and it bothers you.
[00:03:01] Leah Clionsky: Um, one thing that tends to bother parents the most is when, um, they call, we call someone out on something, and they just tell us it's not a big deal. "Oh, Mom, you're overreacting. That's not really a big deal. I don't even know why you're being so dramatic and upset about that." So the "it's not even a big deal" comment is particularly frustrating, because it's the true, like, "I don't even acknowledge a circumstance under which you should care about this."
[00:03:29] Leah Clionsky: So why do kids do this? Why don't they step forward and acknowledge their mistakes? Well, I'll tell you a little story about when this happened to me, I think I was about five years old, and then we can t-- I'll tell you a little bit more about- some of the common reasons, and then we can talk about what you can do about it so that it's much more likely that your child will be more open to talking to you when they mess up So when I was around, I think it was about five, um, my mom used to insist that I do this nap time in my room on a daily basis.
[00:03:59] Leah Clionsky: I think it was about 30 minutes. And I didn't have to sleep. She thought that was unrealistic. But I did have to be in there by myself, and I could be playing quietly or drawing, and I had a little desk and markers. And one day, for whatever reason, I decided I wasn't going to draw on the desk, I wanted to draw in bed.
[00:04:19] Leah Clionsky: So I moved my paper and markers to the bed. I drew this beautiful picture, and when I lifted the piece of paper up, I looked at the bed and realized that the marker had seeped through the paper onto the quilt, and I panicked, right? I felt terrible. I, um, was one of those moments where I still remember just like the panic, like, "Oh, no."
[00:04:41] Leah Clionsky: Like, I didn't know this would happen, and now this is on the quilt, and maybe it will never come off. What do I do about this? I wish I hadn't done that. And because I couldn't turn back time, I did what would make it go away in my mind the fastest, which is I just turned the comforter over, over and hoped my mom would never, ever find out that I did it.
[00:05:00] Leah Clionsky: And then honestly, I then forgot about it because in my mind, like, I solved it. Like, okay, it was on this side, now it's on the other side, we move on. Of course, did my mom eventually go to do the laundry and notice that there was marker on the quilt? Oh, 100%. And then we got to have a conversation about how I needed to come to her if there was a mistake so that we could fix it together.
[00:05:22] Leah Clionsky: But in my mind at the time, it was more of a, less of a, like, being so afraid of her reaction and more of just wanting to undo it. Like, if I do this, it will in some way be undone. It's not very sophisticated. Probably honestly a relatively normal thought process for a five-year-old, but that was my go-to. So sometimes the hiding it is just like, if I don't acknowledge it, maybe it's not true.
[00:05:48] Leah Clionsky: Or if I tell you it's not a big deal, maybe it will not become a big deal, right? Like, maybe I can trick us both into an undoing of this behavior. If I hide it or downplay it enough, maybe no one has to be affected or upset. It's really appealing. Who wouldn't like to just undo things that go wrong? Um, sometimes kids are afraid of us or our reactions.
[00:06:13] Leah Clionsky: You know, that's a very normal reason for hiding things. Or they know there's some sort of consequence that might come with it that they'd like to avoid. Um, or maybe we are really angry and intolerant of their mistakes. So there are a lot of reasons why someone would wanna hide something instead of like taking the true emotional ownership of being able to say, "I did something that caused a problem for someone else."
[00:06:37] Leah Clionsky: Like, my choice to color on this quilt hurt something in my... that I owned that I might not be able to fix. That's maybe a scary idea So it's, I think it's just a strong, strong avoidance either to protect ourselves from consequences or the emotional follow-up, or to, to avoid, um, upsetting someone else. So what do we do about this?
[00:07:00] Leah Clionsky: How can we promote a family culture where we can admit to mistakes and then be able to a- approach them from there, approach them with full acknowledgement that it actually was a big deal? When I think about this, I actually think of research done in the corporate wor- world around this concept called psychological safety.
[00:07:23] Leah Clionsky: So in the business world If we have psychological safety in an organization, people will often report the mistakes that they make to their colleagues and to their supervisor, which is generally a very good thing. If someone doesn't know how to do something or they make a mistake and they hide it, it affects your business in strong ways, just like it affects your family if you don't have all of the information, right?
[00:07:50] Leah Clionsky: If you, someone forgets to buy something at the store and you need that ingredient to cook dinner and they were too scared to tell you, now it's dinner time and you can't make dinner, right? So having someone being willing to come forward. But what does psychological safety mean in a business context?
[00:08:06] Leah Clionsky: What it means is that there's this idea that you have ability to make mistakes and other people around you can tolerate it and not hold it against you. Like it's safe to experiment and make mistakes interpersonally with the people around you. So think about that in your family, right? This idea that mistakes are normalized.
[00:08:30] Leah Clionsky: It is safe to make them with people around you who are not gonna hold it against it forever. Everything you do is not now a quality of who you are. Like it's a, a safe place to experiment. That, by the way, does not make it a consequence-free place to experiment. I'm much more nuanced, nuanced than that. I'm not like, "Well, if you make a mistake, then if you admit it, then there can never be any consequences for it."
[00:08:53] Leah Clionsky: Like sometimes there are consequences for mistakes that we make. So it's not about that, but it's that like you're not going to be deeply judged as a person for having made the mistake. Does that make sense? So how can we create that kind of psychological safety in a family? Well, one thing that we can think about is that you as the parent can be open about making mistakes, which is always hard for us, but let's face it, we're all imperfect anyway.
[00:09:26] Leah Clionsky: So when you make a mistake, talking through that mistake without, you know, calling yourself names or ramping it up outside the level of what it should be, but also taking responsibility is excellent modeling. And it also, you have the most control out of everyone in your house on the culture of your family.
[00:09:45] Leah Clionsky: So this could mean looking at your kids and saying, "Oh no, I forgot to take the chicken out of the freezer on time, and now it's not defrosted for dinner. That means we're gonna have to bring something in, which I really didn't wanna do, but, you know, I was so busy, I completely forgot about this, and I'm sorry about that.
[00:10:06] Leah Clionsky: Um, next time I'm gonna set a timer on my phone so that I'll remember." So, you know, in this example, I'm not saying that I'm a terrible person or an idiot or that I always make mistakes, but it's just that true acknowledgement, like, "I did this. It's on me." Right? You're, you're not blaming it on someone else.
[00:10:22] Leah Clionsky: "You guys distracted me, and I forgot to take the chicken out of the freezer," or, "Your dad was supposed to do it, and he didn't." Right? It's that, like, true responsibility. Like, "I was supposed to do this thing, and I didn't, and this is the, the consequence of having done that, and this is what we're gonna do moving forward."
[00:10:39] Leah Clionsky: So just that modeling and then everyone being able to be like, "Oh, okay," and then move on from it, it makes it a lot less scary to make a mistake. Does that make sense? So the more we can model these kinds of things for our kids, the better they are able to understand them. And by the way, in that literature, having the CEO or the boss or the supervisor talk through their mistakes and acknowledge them is part of cre- creates psychological safety The second thing you can do is when your kids do come to you with a mistake, instead of lecturing, asking questions about what's going on.
[00:11:19] Leah Clionsky: So, you know, "I noticed that there's marker on your quilt. What happened? Tell me what happened." Right? So you're just opening that door. Then your kid can say, "I didn't know that I would-- that when I drew on it, that it would go through, and I should've known, and I'm so upset." And you can, like, be able s- to talk through it.
[00:11:39] Leah Clionsky: "Oh, what do you think happened? What would you do next time?" You know, if you have a kid who is literally standing there saying, "Well, it's not a big deal. It's not even my quilt. Go ahead and buy a new one with your money, Mom." Right? If you have that response, then you kind of get to have another interesting discussion where you're like, "Well, what do you think the impact of that is on other people?"
[00:11:59] Leah Clionsky: And it doesn't have to be framed as like, "Can you see how you affected other people?" But it can be a real place for, for someone to explore a little bit. Like, "What do you think the impact is, was of that decision? Can you see why other people might be upset by it?" So it lets you have a real conversation about the fact that when we make a mistake, it's often not just us that are affected.
[00:12:24] Leah Clionsky: So you're not trying to create this anxiety where you're like, "If you made a mistake, then you're terrible, and, you know, um, everyone's gonna be upset with you." It's more like, we have to discuss it forever. Like, if you just knocked over a water cup, you knocked over a water cup. Like it's, there's no thought how are you gonna change that in the future.
[00:12:40] Leah Clionsky: Stuff just happens, right? But it's more like, you know, if there was something that really someone could have done differently, it's worthwhile to talk about it in a neutral kind of way, be able to problem solve, and be able to offer a different point of view. So being, asking curious questions instead of lecturing can make more psychological safety.
[00:13:03] Leah Clionsky: It can also help you understand what's going on better. Third thing is you wanna praise your kid for telling you the truth. So, you know, there's the incident, and then there's the tolerating your discomfort enough to come to you with the truth, because that's the hard part. It's the acceptance of, "I did make a mistake.
[00:13:23] Leah Clionsky: I did draw on the comforter even though it was an accident. And then now I'm going to acknowledge this and bring it forward to someone else." Like, that is very respectable, and it's definitely worth being independently acknowledged. You know, "I know it was hard for you to tell me the truth here, and I'm really proud of you for doing it, because there are even grown-ups who can't acknowledge their mistakes and tell the truth.
[00:13:48] Leah Clionsky: Like, this is really part of our family value system when you tell the truth about making a mistake, and I really, really am proud of you for doing it." There still could be something that has to happen. Like there might be an apology that needs to be made. You know, if you hurt something of someone else's, maybe you're paying for, for it from your own allowance.
[00:14:07] Leah Clionsky: This is not to say that there could never be a time where there is an appropriate consequence for that behavior, but that still doesn't take away the value of the acknowledgement that a child made. But it's only really possible to that if they see that echoed, right? And if another child makes a mistake, and then you respond, you know, in a neutral, curious way, acknowledging, you know, how much you respect them for coming forward, then that makes it possible if you have other kids for them to say like, "Hey, it's not that bad.
[00:14:41] Leah Clionsky: In fact, it's a really, really good thing to come forward and tell the truth." So it's this hard concept. Um, I think all of us are uncomfortable with the mistakes that we make. I honestly wish all of mine would disappear and no one would ever know, but that's just not the way human beings are wired. And I also think that that message of the fact that everybody makes mistakes, that that's normal, that is part of being a human being, and we can also make sure that the mistakes we make are, um, not mistakes that we could have avoided by simple, simple steps, and also that you can make a mistake that you really wish didn't happen and it can affect somebody else.
[00:15:24] Leah Clionsky: So all of the nuances I think are where the magic of parenting, the complexity of parenting, and sometimes the confusion of parenting really can be. So I'm really interested to hear what you think about this episode. If you have any thoughts, definitely, um, DM me on Instagram. It's Educated Parent Podcast.
[00:15:45] Leah Clionsky: You can contact me there. But I hope you're having a great week, and I will talk to you again next time.