How To Get Your Kid to Actually Try a Vegetable Tonight (with Jennifer Anderson From Kids Eat in Color)

How To Get Your Kid to Actually Try a Vegetable Tonight

You made dinner.

You put a vegetable on your child's plate.

And now you're watching that vegetable sit there completely untouched.

So you try to help.

"Just take one bite."

"You haven't even tried it."

"The carrots are really good tonight."

"Can you please just taste it?"

And somehow, the more enthusiastic you become about that carrot, the less likely your child seems to be to put it anywhere near their mouth.

If you've ever wondered how to get kids to eat vegetables, registered dietitian Jennifer Anderson of Kids Eat in Color has an approach that might surprise you.

Stop trying so hard to get them to eat the vegetable.

In this episode of Educated Parent, Jennifer and I talked about why feeding children can become so emotionally loaded, especially when you're dealing with picky eaters. More importantly, Jennifer gave us simple strategies you can literally try at dinner tonight.

No elaborate recipes.

No hiding spinach in brownies.

You may just need a vegetable, a toothpick, and a willingness to stop caring quite so much about whether your child actually takes the bite.


Why Do We Care So Much About Vegetables?

Before we get to the toothpicks, it's worth asking why vegetables can bring up so much emotion for parents in the first place.

We don't see all foods neutrally.

Think about broccoli.

What word comes to mind?

Probably healthy.

Now think about pizza.

Many of us have been conditioned to immediately categorize that as unhealthy.

Jennifer explained that our culture attaches all kinds of assumptions to food, health, socioeconomic status, education, and even what it means to be a "good" parent.

If your child happily eats Brussels sprouts, you might feel like you're doing something right.

If your child refuses every green object you've ever placed in front of them, you may wonder what you're doing wrong.

But Jennifer offered a much healthier way to measure success:

Your win is putting the food on the table.

Their win is eating it.

Those are two separate things.


Your Child's Bite Isn't Your Parenting Report Card

This distinction is incredibly important.

If your definition of successful parenting depends on what your child does, you're going to feel like you're failing constantly.

Children are learning.

They're unpredictable.

Sometimes they cooperate. Sometimes they don't.

And sometimes they inexplicably reject the food they happily ate three days ago.

The same principle applies to healthy eating for kids.

Nutrition matters. What children eat matters. But if every bite becomes evidence that you're either succeeding or failing as a parent, meals become incredibly high stakes.

You become anxious.

Your child feels your anxiety.

And suddenly everyone is sitting at the table staring intensely at a piece of cauliflower.

That's probably not creating the relationship with food you wanted in the first place.


Why Pressure Can Backfire With Picky Eaters

Nobody particularly enjoys being forced to do something.

Imagine someone repeatedly telling you:

"You need to eat this."

"Come on, just try it."

"It's really good."

"Take one bite."

Even if you were initially open to trying the food, you might start resisting simply because you don't like being pressured.

Kids aren't that different.

Jennifer explained that children know when you're trying to get them to eat something.

They pick up on all our little tricks.

And depending on your child's personality, the pressure itself can become a reason to say no.

This is especially important for picky eaters, who may already feel uncertain or uncomfortable around particular foods.

When the parent increases the pressure, the child can increase the resistance.

So what happens if we do the opposite?


Try Saying: "You Don't Have to Eat It"

Imagine your child stands up at dinner, crosses their arms, and announces:

"Dinner is gross. I'm not eating this."

Instead of arguing, Jennifer recommends a very different response:

"Okay. You don't have to eat it. Just sit with us for a few minutes."

You just removed the battle.

There's nothing left for your child to fight against.

Jennifer used this approach with her own children, including while navigating significant feeding concerns with one of her sons.

Her message remained predictable:

This is what we're having.

We're going to sit together.

You decide whether you're going to eat it.

That doesn't mean parents stop providing structure. In fact, consistency and predictability are central to Jennifer's approach.

The difference is that the parent takes responsibility for what the parent can control rather than trying to control whether the child takes the bite.

That's one of the most useful parenting tips in this entire conversation.


Predictable Parents Can Take Some Stress Out of Dinner

Jennifer's approach isn't simply, Let your child do whatever they want.

It's about clearly separating responsibilities.

You provide the meal.

You provide the opportunity.

You create the structure.

Your child decides whether they're going to eat.

When that structure is predictable, children learn what to expect.

Jennifer also acknowledges one of the biggest fears parents have about this:

What if my child doesn't eat?

What if they're hungry later?

What if they wake up hungry?

What if I lose an entire opportunity to get calories into them?

Jennifer understands that fear personally. One of her children fell off his growth chart, so she knows what it's like to lie awake wondering whether your child is getting enough to eat.

For her family, a predictable bedtime snack helped provide another eating opportunity and reduced some of the pressure around dinner.

She also suggests that if you're nervous about changing your approach, you could practice at breakfast first rather than starting with the meal that already feels the most emotionally charged.

That's an important reminder that you don't have to overhaul family dinner tonight.

You can practice.


Why Dinner Is Often the Hardest Meal

There's another reason learning how to get kids to eat vegetables can feel particularly difficult at dinner.

Everyone is tired.

You've been parenting all day.

Your child has been doing kid things all day.

Dinner is also often the meal where parents put the most effort into providing vegetables and creating a balanced meal.

So now you have tired parents, tired children, lower appetites, and a meal into which you've poured a lot of effort and expectation.

That's a perfect recipe for conflict.

Jennifer's strategies are so useful because they don't ask you to become even more invested in the outcome.

They ask you to lower the stakes.

And that's where we get to toothpick magic.


Strategy #1: Try "Toothpick Magic"

Let's say you want your child to try cauliflower tonight.

Jennifer's first recommendation is not to choose the strangest vegetable they've never encountered before.

Choose something reasonable.

Maybe they've seen cauliflower many times.

Maybe they've tasted it before.

They're just not particularly interested in eating it.

Now get some toothpicks.

That's it.

Put the cauliflower on the table and give everyone toothpicks.

Maybe you put a toothpick into each piece like a tiny hors d'oeuvre.

Maybe everyone gets their own toothpick and gets to stab the cauliflower themselves.

Jennifer calls this "toothpick magic."

Why?

Because toothpicks invite action.

They're novel.

They're fun.

They turn the food into something you can interact with.

And instead of announcing, "Look! I found a fun way for you to eat cauliflower!" you're going to do something even more important.

You're going to leave your child alone.


Strategy #2: Eat the Vegetable Yourself

Pick up your toothpick.

Stab your cauliflower.

Eat it.

If there are other adults or children at the table, they can do the same thing.

And don't spend the entire time watching your hesitant eater to see whether it's working.

Jennifer actually recommends ignoring them.

You might casually notice something about your own food:

"Oh, this cauliflower is crunchy."

Maybe you smell it.

Maybe you listen to see if it makes a sound.

Maybe you say something silly.

The point isn't to perform an elaborate show designed to manipulate your child into eating.

Children will pick up on that.

Instead, you're genuinely interacting with the food yourself and allowing your child to observe.

This is modeling.

And modeling can be an incredibly powerful part of healthy eating for kids because your child gets to watch people they trust interact with the food without feeling like everyone is waiting for them to do the same.


Curiosity Is Better Than Opposition

I've seen this dynamic with my own kids.

My daughter loves vegetables. My son is more hesitant.

If I simply offer him a pepper, he may not be particularly interested.

But if his sister is excited about an orange pepper and talking about how orange it is, suddenly he wants to know what's going on.

"I want to try orange pepper."

Why?

Curiosity.

Kids are joiners.

When other people are genuinely having fun with something, they want to know what they're missing.

That's a completely different emotional state than having a parent hovering over you saying:

"Try the pepper."

When we think about picky eaters, our immediate goal doesn't always have to be consumption.

Maybe the first win is curiosity.

Maybe they stab the cauliflower.

Maybe they smell it.

Maybe they touch it.

Maybe they watch you eat it.

They still may not put it in their mouth tonight.

Jennifer emphasizes that you have to let go of the outcome.

That's difficult, but it also takes an enormous amount of pressure off both of you.


What If They Still Don't Try It?

This is important.

You can do everything Jennifer recommends and your child still may not eat the vegetable.

That doesn't mean the strategy failed.

For a child who is particularly selective about food, expecting one playful dinner to completely change their eating would be unrealistic.

Instead, you've created an experience with the food that wasn't defined by conflict.

Your child saw it.

They interacted with it.

They watched you eat it.

They experienced the food without being pressured to perform.

That's still meaningful.

One of the most valuable parenting tips here is to stop judging every strategy by whether it produces immediate compliance.

Parenting is full of things that work gradually.

Feeding can be the same way.


Strategy #3: Tell Jokes at Dinner

Jennifer's third strategy almost sounds like it has nothing to do with food.

Tell jokes.

Make your child laugh.

Have fun together.

Why would that help?

Because you just changed the focus of dinner.

Instead of everyone concentrating on whether your child is going to eat the vegetable, you're concentrating on connection.

Jennifer explains that reducing anxiety can also change what is happening physically in the body. When we're less stressed, chewing and swallowing can become easier, saliva production changes, and muscles involved in swallowing can relax.

A child facing an unfamiliar or intimidating food may experience real stress around that food.

Connection can help bring that stress down.

So instead of asking:

"How do I make my child eat this?"

Try asking:

"How can we make dinner feel good tonight?"

That's a powerful shift.


Healthy Eating Isn't Just About What Gets Eaten Tonight

This is where Jennifer's larger philosophy around healthy eating for kids becomes particularly important.

The goal isn't simply to produce a child who eats vegetables.

We also want children who develop a healthy relationship with food and with their bodies.

Jennifer's book, Feed Them Well: How to Raise Healthy, Confident Eaters for Life, is designed around that bigger goal.

She wants children to learn to eat a variety of foods, make decisions about what to eat, feel comfortable in their bodies, and eventually navigate food confidently themselves.

That's much bigger than broccoli.

And it's why focusing exclusively on whether your child ate tonight's vegetable can sometimes cause us to lose sight of what we're actually trying to teach.


Parents Need Feeding Confidence, Too

There's another side to this conversation that I think is particularly important.

Many of us weren't taught how to have a healthy, confident relationship with food ourselves.

Maybe you grew up surrounded by diet culture.

Maybe foods were labeled "good" and "bad."

Maybe adults around you were constantly talking about weight.

Maybe you're still trying to figure out how to feed yourself without guilt, restriction, or anxiety.

Now you're supposed to teach your child something you were never taught.

That's hard.

We see the same thing in parenting around emotional regulation. Parents come to us at Thriving Child Center because they're trying to teach children emotional skills they never learned themselves.

Feeding can create a similar challenge.

You're trying to raise a confident eater while simultaneously working through your own history with food.

That deserves compassion.


Three Things You Can Try Tonight

So if you're wondering how to get kids to eat vegetables, here's what Jennifer wants you to try tonight.

First, get some toothpicks.

Pick a vegetable your family already knows and make interacting with it a little more playful.

Second, model eating it.

Don't stare at your child.

Don't repeatedly offer it.

Don't make your enthusiasm fake.

Simply eat, interact with, and enjoy the food yourself.

Third, laugh.

Tell jokes.

Connect.

Make dinner about being together instead of making the entire meal a referendum on whether your child takes a bite of cauliflower.

And remember that your child still might not eat it.

That's okay.

Your Win Is Putting the Food on the Table

For parents of picky eaters, this might be the most freeing message from my conversation with Jennifer:

Your win is when you put the food on the table.

Their win is when they eat it.

Your job isn't to force the second win.

Your job is to provide opportunities, structure, consistency, modeling, and connection.

Those are things you can actually control.

And when we approach healthy eating for kids that way, dinner doesn't have to become a nightly battle over broccoli.

So tonight, try one of these parenting tips .

Get the toothpicks.

Eat the cauliflower.

Tell a terrible joke.

And then see what happens when you stop trying quite so hard to make your child take the bite.


RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE:

Feed Them Well by Jennifer Anderson

LET'S CONNECT:

Thriving Child Center

PCIT Experts

Calm and Connected Program

Instagram

Love having expert tips you can actually use? Join our newsletter and get a beautifully designed PDF of each episode’s top 3 takeaways—delivered straight to your inbox every week.

Are you a provider? Subscribe here for professional insights and parenting resources!

CONNECT WITH JENNIFER ANDERSON:

Website

Instagram

TikTok

Next
Next

Why Parenting Feels Harder During Perimenopause - and What to Do (with Elisabeth Netherton)